Kylie Bisutti Quits Victoria's Secret for Christian Convictions

I stumbled across this news article tonight about Kylie Bisutti, a former Victoria's Secret model. It's crazy to think she's about my age, this young woman who has the same faith I have, but who has been living life on a completely different side of the spectrum -- or so many Christians would think.

It reminds me of the whole "I'd rather have a Proverbs 31 woman than a Victoria's Secret model" topic, which I commented on last week. Here is this woman who has faith in Jesus, but was a Victoria's Secret model at the same time. I'm not condoning her initial decision to be a VS model, but that faith was there. Did being a VS model make her a Proverbs 31 woman? No. Does not being a VS model now make her a Proverbs 31 woman? No.

The Proverbs 31 woman is not real. This former Victoria's Secret model is real, and was no less so when she was still a Victoria's Secret model.

[Looking back on my previous post about the whole Proverbs 31 Woman/Victoria's Secret Model topic, I realize that it might come across that I am anti-Live31. I'm not. I just don't like the slogan that accompanies it, the comparison to a VS model. That's mostly what I think is unhealthy; I don't believe it's the best or necessary approach. As far as Live31 goes, I don't have much against it -- as long as we remember not to measure ourselves by the literal Proverbs 31 woman and remember that Christ is the real standard, not this wife of noble character that no one can find (see Proverbs 31:10).)]

We can't categorize this young woman no more than we can categorize any woman. Giving her the benefit of the doubt, she is a woman living in light of God's grace every day, learning more of His heart and what He desires for her. Additionally, she is a woman who is absolutely beautiful on the outside -- and by the standards of this world -- as well as a woman pursuing God, which makes her beautiful on the inside. So it looks like Kylie fits both "standards" of the Proverbs 31 woman/Victoria's Secret model comparison.

I'm happy for her and the decision she's made -- she's got more conviction than so many of us.

For her interview on Good Morning America, watch here.

Proverbs 31 Woman vs. Victoria's Secret Model

On November 30, 2011, a Baylor University student updated his Facebook status with, "I'd rather have a Proverbs 31 woman than a Victoria's Secret model." The status went viral on Facebook, and a week later, the same Baylor student and a few of his friends had a YouTube video, website (Live31.org) and even their own apparel. It wasn't until another week later that this new Christian trend reached my side of cyberspace, with a large number of my Christian Facebook friends reposting the status, sharing the video and linking the website. I immediately joined in.

Fast forward to a little more than a month later and this Live31 movement shows up on my Facebook newsfeed once again. But this time, instead of quickly "liking" the post, I decided to see what this movement really was about -- and as it turns out, I didn't like what I saw.

I'm sure the founders of this movement mean well, but I believe it needs to be reevaluated. Looking through the website's FAQ section, this caught my eye:

So if the statement, "I'd rather have a Proverbs 31 woman than a Victoria's Secret model," isn't what you really meant, then why make a whole movement out of it? Because it sounds catchy? That's not good enough.

I don't believe this thinking is healthy. First, the Proverbs 31 woman doesn't exist. None of the women of the Bible measured up to this standard, and especially now as our society and culture are different, I don't think Christian women today should be trying to measure up to her either. Of course, there is a lot to be said in that passage because it is Scripture. But we shouldn't take it out of context, and we shouldn't take it so literally. The Proverbs 31 woman is not the standard. Christ is the standard.

I know most of the people who started this movement knew this, and no one meant to offend anyone or limit women. But I think that saying you prefer a Proverbs 31 woman over a Victoria's Secret model can be just as damaging to a woman's essence. What of the women who were created beautiful by God (all women) and are considered beautiful by the world's standards (only some)? Do they have any less value because they are a godly woman AND happen to look like a VS model? No.

And that's just a little of what I think about it. If you want a better idea of what I'm trying to say, read these blog posts:
On Femininity, Sexism, and Sensuality in the Bible
and
Sparks Fly Up: A Response to "I'd Rather Have A Proverbs 31 Woman Than A Victoria's Secret Model".

I don't agree with everything written in them, but I agree with the general idea.

I'm just saying that we should be careful what we fight for, and what we "like." If you don't really mean that you'd rather have a Proverbs 31 woman than a VS model -- and the weight and meaning behind what you are saying -- then don't say it, just because it sounds catchy, just because everyone else is "liking" it. Don't categorize women into "Proverbs 31" and "VS model." Say that you want a woman who strives to imitate Christ and knows she is beautiful because God created her so. Don't settle for cheap words just because they make a nice slogan.